This post will generally assume you’re up to date on Boruto but in case you aren’t here’s a quick grasp of the situation. Boruto’s class is taking a Genin exam and for whatever reason Kakashi is the exam proctor and his doing a variation of his old bell test from Naruto. Boruto’s class ends up passing the exam but during the exam Kakashi ripped into Boruto and his classmates for not being good enough and that’s where about half the intrigue for this test should have been. But I’m getting ahead of myself.
By far one the most interesting aspects of Boruto is the contrast of Boruto’s generation and Naruto’s generation. In the buildup to this exam, an exam which Naruto almost entirely glossed over since Naruto was the only one which couldn’t pass it, though obviously he does end up passing it via learning Shadow Clone. In Boruto this exam is much bigger deal because it will break the class up. Everyone wants to pass this exam because it’s like getting a high school diploma but the class is split between people who want to continue down the ninja path or people who want to get a secondary school education and do something else. Some teams almost fall apart because of the disagreements between those who wanted to be ninjas together and those who want to take their lives elsewhere.
A particularly good scene in the buildup to the exam is when Boruto asks Hinata why she became a ninja. She casually remarks that when she was a kid that was what was expected of people. Boruto just kind of moves on from that scene without really taking it in but there’s almost no greater sign of the differences between the two generations. In Naruto’s time countries were either at war or on the brink of war and ninjas were the lifeblood of every village. Boruto has never experienced such a world and none of the kids can really conceive of it. Few if any of them even have concrete goals or motives with regards to becoming a ninja and as mentioned above plenty of them aren’t even interested in being ninjas and do in fact plan to go elsewhere.
This is where Kakashi’s exam is kind of strong. Kakashi goes incognito and investigates the class and observes their collectively weak or altogether lacking resolve. He pins Boruto down in 1v1 combat and just rips into him about his lack of resolve and the bad influence he has on the rest of the class, and for a second it seems like he might really go ahead with his threats to fail everyone. Ideally in fact I think none of them should have passed the exam. It would have been really cool if the adults had made them face the fact they really aren’t ready to be ninja because the ninja world is a much more brutal place than they realize. Imagine the amount of time they could spend developing characters after such a major failure, with some people dropping out for real this time, other’s hardening their resolve and so on. Hell the impact of such a scene would have been phenomenal too a loud smack from an uncaring reality against the mostly happy-go-lucky tone of Boruto, the show and the character.
Alas this is where the exam falls apart, because the real point was to make sure the kids worked together and didn’t abandon their comrades – teaching the “those who break the rules are scum but those who abandon their friends are worse than scum” lesson we saw in Naruto. But what was the point of that? Boruto and friends are a hell of a lot more willing to cooperate and look out for each other because to them that’s, well, normal. This is not an age of war where the best could and sometimes would look down on their squadmates or when leaving comrades to die for the sake of mission was considered acceptable and even normal. The reason Kakashi’s exam made sense in the past was that it clashed with the established norms of sacrificing people to ensure the team succeeded overall. And with regards to team 7 specifically it was used to unite the fractious 3 genin under Kakashi’s command. Boruto and friends need no such push to unite them nor do they need to be convinced they should do things for the sake of their friends, that’s practically all they’ve done up until this point.
What the kids really need is a wake up call, something to really spell out for them how dangerous the world they are trying to step into can be. Instead of being about uniting to get the Kakashi’s bell the exam really should have been something like the whole class having to beat the instructors in combat or, though impractical and out of character, the whole class trying to even hit Naruto. I’m fine with them all passing the test so long as they learn a lesson about the realities of the ninja world. Naruto himself would be ideal to show the kids just how unreasonably powerful their opponents could theoretically be while a maybe using the Ino, Choji and Shikamaru team to beat the whole class could really hit home how deadly enemies working together can be. The point of the exam should not be about being a good friend anymore, that problem has been solved, rather the new genin exam should be a lesson in humility that challenges the half baked ambitions and resolve of the kids. It should make them confront whether they really want to be ninjas or not because unlike in Naruto’s time, not being a ninja is an option with no stigma attached. And I feel like Kakashi himself sort of agrees with me because he remarked that they had made the test too easy for Boruto’s class shortly before they passed it.
Long story short I think this exam shows both some real sparks of intrigue in Boruto and also the problems of sticking too close to Naruto in terms of writing. The audience already knows all about this test and the lesson it teaches and it’s not given much weight or time at all because it’s a formality for the viewer. Likewise it doesn’t even effect the kids too much. However in the buildup to the exam and the split second where it seemed like Kakashi might actually fail everyone we saw glimpses material that could make for great character stories. Ultimately I think what needs to happen is that in the near future Boruto and friends have to be confronted with the differences between them and their parents in the most stark and serious manner possible, because that will challenge them a hundred times more than this exam did and it will cut to the heart of their character as individuals, while highlighting some of the serious differences between the world of Naruto’s childhood and Boruto’s childhood.