Jesus I never thought I would have to put those two words together. I’m not going to lie this whole post is going to be extremely petty and not particularly important. But after seeing how the latest episode of Shokugeki no Soma played out and having seen how both My Little Pony and Power Puff Girls put out anti-social justice episodes years ago, I can only believe that this was done on purpose to attack social justice. And that’s fucking hilarious.
In case you’re not caught up on things, the recent events are as follows. Six members of the Elite Ten have voted to oust Erina’s grandpa as the principal and replace him with Erina’s dad, Azami- who it turn’s out is a psychotic, manipulative asshole aiming for a gourmet utopia using Erina’s God Tongue as a the centerpiece of this utopia. I have a handful of problems about the setup of the whole arc but I’ll do that at the end. Right now we have funnier shit to address.
So the first thing Azami does, besides insult all kind of industry heavyweights in first appearance, is call for the dissolution of all clubs and “autonomous groups.” This ends up including the Polar Star Dorm because it’s totally self sufficient thanks to the efforts of prior generations. In addition to destroying all independent groups, Azami also creates a group called Central which will decide the cooking curriculum for the entire school, by which I mean not only what people HAVE to cook but also how the HAVE to cook it. Individual flair and experimentation are not welcome in Azami’s communist Totsuki Academy. This obviously pisses off a huge section of the student body and of course the audience, and I’ll go ahead say that was the point.
The only seemingly redeeming feature of the Azami administration is that Totsuki will abandon it’s hilariously over the top meritocratic system that would see 90% of the students fail so that the best 10% can reach their maximum power level. Azami calls this unfair (which it is but so is life) because people learn at different speeds, so under his new system everyone will graduate so long as they follow Central’s rules. The flaws in this system are immediately apparent when it drags down Ibusaki, one the Polar Star members, because he performs one step of cooking a dish differently than instructed. It’s amazing how quickly and how thoroughly they make Azami’s reign look bad and that’s before Eizan allows people to challenge him Shokugeki’s to avoid having their clubs disbanded, but buys out the judges and proves to the whole school the contest will be blatantly unfair.
This is fucking hilarious. I love the fact that a cooking show of all things immediately demonstrates the problems with communism and social justice attitudes of equality and fairness. Central deprives the students of their freedom, individual expression and most importantly for their careers, their merit. The only people who benefit from Central are the leadership and Central itself, as well as the students who aren’t in any clubs and/or are most likely to fail. The equality Azami speaks of doesn’t make anyone better it just drags everyone who was already better down. Also the system shows how corrupt it is right off the bat by allowing Eizan to do away with fair challenges. He even explains that he’s doing it to crush everyone’s spirit into following the new way of things. They even make note of the fact that 3 of the 4 members not involved with Azami have been missing since all the chaos began. You could hardly paint a more accurate comparison of communism in the context of a culinary school. Seriously all that’s missing are the mass executions and famines, i.e. expulsions and lose of industry support.
Which is of course what would absolutely happen. If Central was not challenged and beaten, which it will have to be for self-evident reasons I’m about to get to, Totsuki would die. Azami has this vision of a gourmet utopia but not only is it incredibly limited in scope of meal choices in comparison to the wider market it’s also suicidally limited in who it will serve. Keep in mind that Azami believes even industry heavyweights aren’t all good enough and that Erina, and by extension Central, will have to select from a tiny customer base. The market would kill this shit off in an instant which is why, manga spoilers, Azami sets his sights on wiping out all restaurants in Japan which don’t follow his credo, because if he didn’t his utopia would be bankrupt in a week. Does that sound dystopian enough for you yet? Because, more spoilers, he even has professors who go out of their way to sabotage people who reject Central’s teaching, in much the same way we have professors who join Antifa to hit people on the head with bikelocks for disagreeing with them.
Moreover with such a sizable percentage of students, some of them among the best in the academy, up in arms it’s hard to see how this could even be remotely viable. Given that Azami pissed off all the industry heavyweights whom he thinks aren’t good enough and all the students who want to focus on their individual cooking style, the previous principal could legit just start a new school and destroy Azami’s Totsuki. The old man already has all the connections he needs and if he gave them the option of another great cooking school all the students opposing Azami’s rules cold just up and leave. In addition Azami’s style could ruin Totsuki’s reputation all on it’s own, reducing the allure of the academy by default and thus giving anyone fed up with his style no reason to stay.
Naturally none of this happens because that would be a buzzkill for the characters in the story even if people like me would find it deeply satisfying. There is however a fly in the ointment, a bone I have to pick the with creators – Rindou. In comparison to most of the other Elite Ten members Rindou has by far the most exotic and chaotic cooking style, most of the other Elite Ten are masters of a certain traditional dish or genre, Rindou’s only real competition with regards to bizarre dishes is Soma, his dad, and one of my favorite side characters Sadatsuka. It would not entirely be out of character for Rindou to get Azami in control to shake things up, but his vision is utterly incompatible with her style and she shows no signs of compromising her style for anyone. It would make more sense if she got Azami in power and then immediately turned on him for the sake of battling the other Elite Ten – probably just for the fun of it.
That’s all I had to say really. I can’t confirm that the creators of Shokugeki no Soma are in fact anti-social justice. But even if they aren’t they did a hell of a job illustrating what the problems of communism and social justice attitudes about being fair are. And that alone is well worth watching season 3 for, it definitely helped spice up a season that is much slower than it’s predecessors because of how close it is to catching up to the manga. I hope you enjoyed this inane babble and I of course hope you enjoy the show. Shadilay my dudes.